Author Of One Of France’s Biggest Hit Novels Of The Year Accused Of Using AI
Grasset says it has absolute confidence in Thélyson Orélien as the novel’s sales pass 35,000 and prize juries weigh it for major awards.
- A Goncourt finalist, the novel faces accusations of being AI-written after Pangram claimed testing the manuscript obtained "the same result: 100% AI," sparking debate across France.
- On Monday 21 September, an anonymous account posted claims the book was produced by artificial intelligence, and the account has since gained more than 6,600 followers.
- Grasset defended the author, expressing "their absolute confidence" against any attempt to "measure, standardise or silence writing that is forever free," while the author cited a Haitian and Caribbean literary tradition.
- Late in the evening, the five people behind the account posted a message calling to "go easy on the attacks against" the author, acknowledging "there is a non-zero chance" he is acting in good faith.
- While Pangram claims a "false-positive rate of 0.0041%," the novel continues to sell more than 35,000 copies and remains a finalist for The Goncourt, with prizes to be announced on Tuesday 3 November.
12 Articles
12 Articles
(Berlin=Yonhap News) Correspondent Kim Gye-yeon = Ahead of the French literary awards season, artificial intelligence (AI) ghostwrote the works of Haitian authors who were nominated one after another...
The novel 'C’était ça ou mourir' is being controversial after several AI detectors have identified different fragments as artificial; the author has denied having used these toolsAgustín Fernández Mallo: “Governments have to legislate seriously to what extent they allow AI into politics” The Goncourt Academy, responsible for one of the most prestigious French-language literature awards, has asked on Wednesday to act cautiously in the face of the…
Literary sensation accused of using AI to write prize-winning novel
A breakout star author is accused of using AI in his prize-contending debut
'C'était Ça ou Mourir,' the debut novel by Haitian-Quebecois writer Thélyson Orélien, has been a hit in France. But an anonymous account on X started a firestorm after claiming to have scanned the book through an AI detection tool.
Author Of One Of France’s Biggest Hit Novels Of The Year Accused Of Using AI
C’était ça ou mourir (It Was That Or Die) by Thélyson Orélien has sold over 35,000 copies and been hailed in France’s literary mediasphere as a revelation. On Monday, an anonymous X (Twitter) account claimed the AI-spotting software Pangram found that “this novel was written almost entirely by an artificial intelligence.” – Euronews
The AI has unexpectedly slipped into the race for the achievement of the Goncourt award, the most prestigious award of French letters. On the 21st, an anonymous account in X, Balance ton Claude, published a message in which it was stated that much of the fragments of one of the candidate works, 'C'etait ca ou mourir' (It was that or die), of the Haitian-Canadian author Thélyson Orélien, were the work of artificial intelligence.
Coverage Details
Bias Distribution
- 40% of the sources lean Left, 40% of the sources lean Right
Factuality
To view factuality data please Upgrade to Premium










