Overnight Stabbing Death Leads to Arrest of Mt. Victory Man

Overnight Stabbing Death Leads to Arrest of Mt. Victory Man

(Andrew McCafferty being held in Multi County Jail on murder charge) The Hardin County Central Dispatch Center received a 9-1-1 call on October 1st, 2025 at 0003 hours regarding a stabbing incident in Mount Victory, Ohio. Responding Sheriff deputies arrived to find James Collins, 48, of Mount Victory in the street suffering from several stab wounds. Collins was treated by EMTs with Southeast Hardin Northwest Union Fire Department and he was tran…

Hardin County Stabbing Murder

Andrew McCafferty (10-1-25) The Hardin County Sheiff’s Department is investigating a stabbing murder that took place early this morning. The murder happened in Mt. Victory, the victim was James Collins (48) of Mt. Victory. The suspect in the murder is Andrew McCafferty (46) of Mt. Victory.