Evander, the MLS leader in goal contributions, finished the comeback with his sixth outside-the-box goal this season.
On Wednesday, FC Cincinnati defeated NYCFC 2-1 with midfielder Evander scoring the decisive goal in stoppage time to secure the victory.
The win improves Cincinnati's season record to 8-6-6, while NYCFC holds a 9-4-3 historical advantage in head-to-head matchups against the club.
Forward Kenji Mboma Dem opened the scoring in the 11th minute; forward Luighi Hanri Sousa Santos equalized for NYCFC in the 21st minute after a cross from midfielder Agustin Ojeda.
Goalkeeper Roman Celentano made seven saves, including back-to-back stops in the second half, preserving the score. Evander, the 28-year-old midfielder leading MLS with 22 goal contributions, secured the decisive win.
Cincinnati aims to build momentum in the series, which saw a 4-4 tie on April 22 at Yankee Stadium involving players Andrei Chirila and Kevin Denkey in a dramatic prior matchup.